15 Aug
Review: Scott Pilgrim VS The World
So at long last, the weekend is upon us. Scott Pilgrim is out in theaters, for all to see. But how does it stack up? There has been a bit of hype built up around this movie. Respected source material, well respected director with a unique style and some decent names (Michael Cera, Brandon Routh, Chris Evans, Jason Schwartzman). But these can also make things harder, with that much source material, it is possible to make a decent adaptation? Let’s see.
My first experience with Scott Pilgrim was seeing the trailer for the first time on Kotaku. Cited as a video game reference movie, I watched it. Then I watched it again. Then I watched it again. I was enamored, it looked really awesome and quite a bit silly. Then I read down in the comments section that it was basic on some comics. Curiosity piqued, I snatched those right up and read ‘em all in a day, and I really enjoyed them. They do start off a little slow, but once Ramona shows up and the fights began, I was hooked. Each subsequent volume was better, culminating with the recently released volume six, which was my favorite.
So good source material, check. Ok, what’s next? Well, movies need directors, and this directors was no slouch. Famous for being ‘the third guy behind the camera’ with Simon Pegg and Nick Frost, Edgar Wright did an awesome job conveying his very cool and unique vision for the movie. Having perfected his style with Shaun of the Dead and Hot Fuzz, he was an excellent choice and he did an awesome job. I really liked his adaptation, he did a great job, he was passionate, and I can’t really say there’s anyone I’d rather have seen direct it.
Next, the cast. They really did a great job. I’ll admit, I was a bit nervous at first with Michael Cera being cast as Scott as the role was a little more cocky than his normal parts, but it appears my fears were unfounded and he did a very fine job. Rest of the cast was great, too. I really enjoyed Schwartzman in movies like Rushmore and The Darjeeling Limited, so it was a pleasure to see him as Gideon. Chris Evans, aka the new Captain America, and Brandon Routh, aka Superman and that guy from Chuck, did great jobs as Lucas Lee and Todd respectively, two of Ramona’s evil exes. The rest of the cast were all unknowns to me, but they all did a great job. Mary Elizabeth Winstead did a fantastic job as the aloof and mysterious Ramona, and suddenly has many many fanboy crushes on her. Kieran Culkin (Macaulay’s younger brother) almost stole the show as Wallace, Scott’s gay and hilarious roommate. Alison Pill and Mark Webber did great as Kim Pine and Stephen Stills, the other members of the Sex B-ombs. Anna Kendrick did great as the sarcastic younger Stacey Pilgrim. Really, the whole cast did great with their roles.
I have to say I really did enjoy the movie. It was the best adaptation they could have made. No, it was not 100% true to the source, but given the amount of content in six 150-200 page graphic novels, some creative editing was required. The end result was a wildly entertaining and fantastic ride. I was laughing throughout most of the movie, pop culture references galore. From Zelda to the Seinfeld scene, it’s a fast paced thrill ride, full of amusing characters and great action moments. I was very pleased and happy. Was very amusing watching Scott try to hookup with the way-out-of-his-league Ramona.
(Minor spoilers ahead)
I have to say, the end made me nervous at first. It hints at the possibility that Scott ends up with the wrong girl. In both the comics and movie, I never really liked the parts with the particular younger character, nothing against the actress, just didn’t like Scott’s relationship with her, so when movie hints Scott may end up with her instead of the proper girl, I was ready to be upset. But in the end Scott goes with who he’s supposed to. I have no problem that the end’s different from the comics, I understand the ending in the book is too long for film, that’s fine. Just have to have Scott end up with the proper girl in the end.
I heard someone mention that Scott Pilgrim VS the World was the best video game movie made. And I can’t say that I disgree. While not based on a video game, it really has the feel one one. A princess to win, seven bosses, and wild over the top action, all the elements are there. It really is a great movie and you do need to see it. And while I may like the comics more, that’s only because there’s more time to flesh things out and see more of the characters and their interactions. I did feel the ending in the comics was more satisfying, I really enjoyed the movie and came away with a big grin on my face. Please go see it, I’d really like to see this movie do well in the box office.
–theindiegeek out.




















